How to Ask for Advice (Without Looking Dumb)

And get the help you actually need

Nik/Unsplash+

Your boss is staring at you, waiting for your recommendation on the website redesign. You presented three solid options, but honestly? You're not sure which one is right. You spent weeks analyzing this alone, and now you realize you should have asked your colleagues for input. Too late.

Sound familiar? You're not alone. Most of us have been taught that successful people are those who help others, not those who need help. We've bought into what Brené Brown calls “the myth that successful people are those who help rather than need, and broken people need rather than help.”

This is backward. The executives who never ask for advice are the ones who actually look incompetent.

Research backs this up: Asking for advice makes you look smarter, not dumber.

But you need to know how to ask.

The Surprising Science of Seeking Help

Everything we think we know about asking for advice is wrong. In our self-help-obsessed culture, seeking guidance feels like admitting defeat. However, Amanda Palmer, in The Art of Asking, argues we should not just accept help when offered – we should actively seek it.

Multiple studies reveal something surprising: When you ask someone for advice, they don't think less of you. They actually rate you as more competent, confident, and likable.

Everyone wins. The person giving advice gets an ego boost ("I'm smart, that's why people ask for my opinion") while you gain both the insight you need and a stronger personal relationship.

Researchers found that people who were asked for advice consistently rated the advice seeker higher on competence. It creates a positive feedback loop – each interaction makes both parties more open to helping each other.

Yet most of us would rather fail publicly than ask for help privately.

Asking for help requires intellectual humility – acknowledging that you don’t have all the answers. Seeking advice promotes curiosity, builds relationships, and accelerates your learning curve.

However, asking everyone for advice can dramatically backfire.

What Smart People Do Wrong

The research also reveals how many advice-seeking attempts backfire. Asking for help is not the problem – it’s the way we ask.

Mistake #1: Running a poll instead of seeking input

I see this happen with managers a lot. They ask everyone and their mother for opinions, then wonder why nobody takes their requests seriously. When you consult too many people, three things happen. First, you end up overwhelmed by multiple, even conflicting advice. Second, you look clueless. Third, you signal that you won't actually follow anyone's guidance.

Research shows that advisors feel offended when advice seekers ignore their recommendations. People want to feel important, not like they're one voice in a crowd.

Unfortunately, most senior executives tend to disregard advice from experts. The reason? They place greater weight on their own opinions – being right matters more than making the right decision.

More than half of advice seekers admit they'll ignore the guidance they receive, regardless of what it is. If that's your approach, you're better off not asking at all.

Before asking for help, follow Darren Hardy’s advice: “Never ask advice of someone with whom you wouldn’t want to trade places.”

Mistake #2: Seeking comfort instead of truth

Mark Twain once said, "Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it is time to pause and reflect." Yet most of us ask for advice from those who make us feel comfortable – friends, close colleagues, and people who are like us.

Research shows that CEOs consistently seek advice from executives who share their backgrounds and perspectives. We're more likely to ask for guidance from people we like and dismiss input from those we don't get along with, even when the latter might be more qualified to help us.

Next time you need advice, choose the most competent person, not the one closest to you.

Mistake #3: Not emptying your cup

We can't learn new things if we can't let go of our existing ideas. Unlearning is all about subtracting. To make room for new ideas, you must first empty your mental cup.

What's the point of asking for advice if you're not genuinely open to unexpected answers? Other people can see your problem from angles you've never considered. They don't think like you – and that's precisely why their perspective matters.

But most of us ask for advice secretly hoping the person will validate what we already think. We've decided what to do, and now we want someone smart to confirm we're right. This isn't advice-seeking – it's approval-seeking, and others can smell it from a mile away.

The advice that feels most uncomfortable is usually the advice you most need to hear.

Get rid of your preconceived ideas by asking, “What if I am wrong about this?” Knock down your ideas before asking for help. This will make you more receptive to new perspectives.

How to Get the Help You Actually Need

Asking for advice is often seen as a sign of weakness. That’s why people fail to convey a clear message. If you need help, ask like you mean it – be clear and intentional.

After analyzing what works (and what doesn't), here's a framework that gets results consistently:

1. Be direct

People are busy. They don't owe you their time, and they have no obligation to help you.

“Can I pick your brain?" sounds too casual and transactional. Instead, show that you value their specific perspective:

“I’m struggling with a team member who delivers great work but consistently misses deadlines. Your experience managing creative teams would be incredibly valuable here.”

2. Come prepared

Too little context is as bad as too much. The clearer the ask, the better the input.

When asking for advice, consider these three elements:

- Clear articulation of the problem – and what success looks like

- Why do you need their help?

- Your ideas: What you've tried that didn't work, or ideas you considered but are not convinced about

Preparation serves two purposes: It shows respect for their time, and it helps them give you targeted, actionable advice instead of generic platitudes.

3. Ask for specific help

Before reaching out, define what kind of help you need. Are you looking for:

- Pros and cons to help you choose between options?

- Someone to challenge your assumptions?

- Strategic mentorship for a big career move?

- A framework to better define the real problem?

- A colleague to brainstorm alternative solutions?

Generic requests get generic responses. The more specific your request, the better advice you’ll get.

4. Set clear expectations

Explain how their advice will factor into your decision-making process. Tell them upfront why you chose them specifically – and if you're consulting multiple people. This prevents hurt feelings and shows you’re strategic, not desperate.

"I plan to synthesize the input and decide by [timeline]. I'm also talking to [type of person] to get a different angle. I'll circle back to let you know what I choose and how your perspective influenced my thinking."

5. Be ready to be challenged

This is the hardest one.

Choose the right person, not your closest ally.

Who’s most qualified to critically analyze options? Who has no problem pushing back? Who’s an expert on X topic that knows much more than you do?

The most valuable advice often comes from people who have no stake in the outcome – and can see the blind spots you’re missing.

6. Close the loop

Follow up and follow through. Thank people and let them know what you decided and how their advice shaped your thinking. This isn't just politeness; it's relationship building.

People hate transactional colleagues – good luck if you build a reputation for asking for help and then disappearing.

Even the most important people appreciate genuine gratitude. That thank-you note won't just boost their egos. It will make them more likely to help you again.

Ask Better, Give Better

Here's the final truth: The best advice-seekers become the best advice-givers. When you learn how to ask for help effectively, you also learn how to give it.

The leaders who rise fastest aren't the ones with all the answers. They're the ones who find the right answers by asking the right people the right questions.

As Cicero said, 'Nobody can give you wiser advice than yourself.' But sometimes, you need other people's perspectives to discover what you already know.

Think of one decision you're facing right now. Who's the best person to ask? Send that message today.

Connect & Collaborate With Gustavo

• New to the Demystify Culture newsletter? Subscribe for free.

• Let’s connect on LinkedIn

• Explore my culture design services

• Join our upcoming Culture Design Masterclass: Book your seat for June, July, and August masterclasses